Skip to content

Should I go to Mallorca or Menorca?

Woman hiking alongside a quiet bay, Cala Tuent, in Mallorca. Copyright @ Christopher Ison

We’re often asked whether Mallorca or Menorca is better, and of course, given that we offer both hiking and cycling holidays there, we’re going to big up both Balearics. There are some differences between the two, however, which is why we are comparing and contrasting them both, to help you choose one island idyll over the other. One thing’s for sure, however. If you choose one, you’re almost guaranteed to seek out the other island very soon. Because that Balearic trance gets you every time. 

Looking out from Menorca to Mallorca across the sea. It’s so beautiful. Video © Catherine Mack

Should I go to Mallorca or Menorca for hiking holidays?

Mallorca (also known as Majorca) is not only the largest of the Balearics, at 3,640km², it’s also the most mountainous, with the Serra de Tramuntana range creating a strong spine along its north coast. So if you want elevation, Mallorca is for you. If you’re a worshipper of coastal walking, Menorca is like manna from adventure heaven. It’s also the greenest of the Balearics, thanks to its north-eastern location which brings more rain and wind, but no shortage of sunshine. 

Cala Mitjana from the Camí de Cavalls path in Menorca. Photo © Catherine Mack

Is hiking harder in Mallorca or Menorca? 

Mallorca is definitely tougher on the knees, as there are steep ascents and descents. So walking poles are a must, although I only brought one, as I find it a hassle to have two personally. But some of these hikes are also on seriously stony terrain, and you need the poles for stability and also stamina. My partner had never used them before and was hesitant, and now says he couldn’t have walked there without them. We do have walking holidays in Mallorca with different difficulty levels, however, so check out all the options. 

We only have one option for walking in Menorca, however, and it’s graded as moderate. There are no mountains, just elevated ridges that dip down to cooling beaches just when you need to treat your tootsies. On this tour, you have daily walking distances ranging from 10-17km and no steep descents and ascents, as well as plenty of transfers to and from trailheads. It isn’t a walk in the park, however, and you definitely need to push yourself a bit. Then have a quick dip to recover. 

Walking on the Archduke’s Trail in Mallorca. Photograph by Christopher Ison ©

What about cycling holidays in Mallorca and Menorca? 

We have cycling holidays on both Mallorca and Menorca, but the former is a favourite with pro cyclists, as the Serra de Tramuntana gift these go-getters with eleven peaks over 1,000m. Our most popular road cycling holiday in Mallorca is an island circuit that’s rated moderate to strenuous, with daily distances ranging from 40-118km over nine days, which is suitable for very active cyclists with an excellent level of fitness. We have a slightly more relaxed itinerary, which takes you on routes of between 39-76km, also over nine days and still an island circuit. In addition, we have an eight day easier cycling itinerary in Mallorca, starting in the northern medieval town of Sineu and ending in Pollença, with trails where the Serra de Tramantuna are more of a backdrop than backbreaking. There is an option for e-bikes on all of our cycling holidays in Mallorca, however. 

Menorca is a little more mellow, categorised, with cycling that’s categorised as moderate, covering 30-42km daily on mainly asphalt roads. On this cycling holiday (where e-bikes are also an option) you follow a carefully-crafted mix of both inland and coastal, from coastal pine to inland oaks forests, Mediterranean coves to the dunes and lagoons of the island’s UNESCO Biosphere Reserve.

The Serra de Tramuntana range is never far from sight on a cycling holiday in Mallorca.

What are the famous hiking trails on Mallorca and Menorca? 

You dip in and out of two main trails on Mallorca on our walking holidays. The first is the GR221 route, which takes you through the heart of the Serra de Tramuntana and is so rugged, it’s called La Ruta de Pedra en Sec or the Dry Stone Route locally. We don’t cover all 150km of it on our walking holidays in Mallorca, but you do get some seriously panoramic highs. The second is the Archduke’s Trail, or Camí de s’Arxiduc, named after the Austrian aristocrat who mapped out this route in the 19th century and then kindly created a trail here. It follows a route through the Serra Tramuntana’s oak forests and rocky cliffside trails in and around Valldemossa, where highlights include the ancient forest of Pla des Pouet which leads up to Pico El Teix (1,263m). 

Menorca’s walking star is the Camí de Cavalls, which is a 185km trail that encircles the island’s coast. It was built in the 14th century by King James II and his occupying forces, to give access for his knights and horses to protect the island. Which is why it’s also called the Horseman’s Trail. Highlights along the way include S’Albufera des Grau Nature Park, the rugged Cap de Favàritx and lighthouse and a magnificent collection of ravines, and a colossal collection of calas. If combining swimming with hiking is your passion, get ready for a double whammy on the Camí. 

Cala de Pilar on Menorca’s Camí de Cavalls. Your feet never get too hot hiking here.

When are the best times to travel to Mallorca and Menorca? 

The best time for walking or cycling in Mallorca is, basically, when it’s not too hot, as Mallorcan temperatures are the highest of all the islands, with average maximum temperatures of 31.5C in August. Which is why many of our holidays don’t run during that time. Our Mallorca holidays are available as early as February, however, and as late as October. We do have one walking holiday in Mallorca that is available all the way through from February to November, but the others take a break in July and August.

Menorca has a shorter season and is much quieter outside June, July and August than Mallorca. The best time for walking in Menorca is between April and June, and then throughout September and October, avoiding peak season and peak temperatures. Our cycling holiday has a longer season, however, running from March to November, but with no trips in July or August. For more information, see our more detailed Guide on walking and cycling in the Balearics. 

Which is busier, Menorca or Mallorca? 

Mallorca is busier, as it’s the larger island, and it has more resort tourism than Menorca, so more flights go there. Mallorca also has significantly more cruise ships arriving into the Port of Palma de Mallorca. As our holidays take you to the island’s mountain trails, you are well away from the crowds, but you may feel more of a bruising from the cruising, when their excursion coaches land in the likes of Valldemossa and Sóller in peak season. 

In contrast, Menorca’s primary port, Mahon (Mao), is a much smaller, quieter harbour. It typically handles only about 50 to 60 cruise ship calls per year, focusing mostly on boutique lines and smaller luxury vessels. And on our walking and cycling holidays, you only spend one or two nights in the port at the beginning or end of the tours. For more insights, see my blogs, Walking Menorca’s Camí de Cavalls and Full disclosure (and exposure) on hiking in Mallorca. 

Is it windier in Mallorca or Menorca? 

You get the Tramuntana winds in both Mallorca and Menorca. It can be a fierce one too, although it does affect each island differently. In Mallorca, it predominantly hits the windward northern coasts and Serra de Tramuntana mountains. The mountains also shelter the southern parts of the island. So if you’re walking the high trails, you definitely need to check wind speeds and monitor weather forecasts, as you do in all mountain landscapes. 

As Menorca is much flatter and lacks the protective mountain barrier that Mallorca has, when the Tramuntana blows here, you will feel it big time, as it sweeps across the whole island. April is its favourite time, bringing with it lower temperatures and sometimes rain, but not always. But be prepared and look ahead at the forecast. 

Walking in the wind in Mallorca. Photograph by Christopher Ison ©

Should I go to Mallorca or Menorca for solo hiking? 

Both are sublime for solo hiking, although if you’re new to walking alone, Menorca has a more obviously waymarked trail in the Camí de Cavalls. And it’s harder to go wrong, as you have the sea as your guide for most of the way, and also more transfer points, where a driver will be waiting to meet you. Although Menorca is smaller, you’ll be surprised how quiet the trails are, especially in the shoulder seasons of spring and autumn, so you still need to ensure you put safety measures in place. But if it’s peace and quiet you’re after, and a mindful time walking, both islands are perfect. For more tips, take a look at my blog, Solo hiking trips for women. 

We hope that you found these Balearic pointers useful. You may also enjoy the following Balearic blogs: Guide to cycling and walking in the Balearics, Walking Menorca’s Camí de Cavalls and Full disclosure (and exposure) on hiking in Mallorca. For more information, please don’t hesitate to contact our team of adventure specialists or click on the holidays linked below.

Share this